Ranking 2023 eyeshadow palettes

I tried 86 eyeshadow palettes in 2023 and today I am ranking all of them! Some of these won’t come as a surprise but I had quite a divided year. I either loved or really disliked the palettes I tried. There was hardly any middle ground. Let’s get stuck in.

2023 eyeshadow palette ranking

As we get to what I loved most, you’ll certainly see a type of product that I just loved the most. There truly is a mixed bag here: from indie to drugstore and from high end to luxury. So I hope you’d like to strap in and get comfortable because this is a long one.

Ranking 2023 Palettes // All the eyeshadow palettes I tried in 2023 from worst to best

Mentioned in the video:

  • Essence Welcome to Marrakesh
  • Catrice Pro Slim Blushing Ocean
  • Oden’s Eye Merry Christmas
  • Oden’s Eye Christmas Eve
  • Make Up Revolution Zodiac Air
  • Kruidvat Sky Like This
  • Viseart Petites Cool Mattes
  • WakeMake Mix Blurring Forest Brown
  • Alter Ego Goddes
  • Alter Ego Coastal
  • Alter Ego Midsummer
  • Rival Hearts Me Out of Space
  • BBIA Tea House Final Shadow Merengue
  • Catrice Metaface
  • Vieve Ninetease
  • Adept Cosmetics Minka
  • Kiko Milano Soft Nude 01
  • NYX Ultimate Utopia
  • Oden’s Eye Jewels & Gem
  • Kiko Milano Joyful Holiday Green as Hope
  • Florasis Goddess
  • Essence Trust Your Intuition
  • Essence Protect Your Energy
  • Viseart Petit Fours Lavande
  • Kaja Bento Rosewater
  • 3CE Multi Eye Color palette Plot Twist
  • Catrice Cozy Earth
  • Viseart London Étoile
  • Holika Holika My Fave Mood Neat Knit & Button Up
  • Sydney Grace Sweet Indulgence
  • Colourpop Off Melrose
  • Peripera Fall in Acorn
  • Catrice Wow in a Box Peach Perfect
  • Tarte Tartelette Energy
  • Nomad Verona Amor et Morte
  • Melt Gemini II
  • Viseart San Francisco Étoile
  • Glamshop Veri Peri
  • Glamshop Fiolety
  • Rom&nd Better Than Peony Nude Garden
  • Colourpop Petals en Pointe
  • Viseart Petit Fours Lilas Deux
  • Shroud Cosmetics Moonfall
  • Colourpop La_vish
  • Nomad Monteverde Cloud Forest
  • Zoeva Velvet Love Beautiful Bright Eyes Glorious Golden Eyes Emerald Green Eyes
  • LH Cosmetics Daybreak
  • What’s Up Geodes
  • Lisa Eldridge Sorcery
  • Colourpop Pretty Please
  • Wycon Glam Eyes Coolest Shades
  • Gloss Gods Dancing in the Sky
  • Sydney Grace Heaven on Earth
  • Viseart Petit Fours Violetta
  • Bella Beaté Bar Smokey Glam
  • Colourpop Troublemaker
  • Pat McGrath Moonlit Seduction
  • Natascha Denona Retro Glam
  • Sydney Grace Love’s Journey
  • Colourpop Deja Brew
  • ELF Celestial Winter
  • Fantasy Cosmetica Fighter
  • Glamshop Niezłe Ziółko
  • Glamshop Kaszmir
  • Gloss Gods Smoke & Mirrors
  • Kaleidos Makeup Alma Viva Twilight Rush
  • MUA Enchantment & Andromeda Skies
  • Essence Welcome to Capetown
  • Clio Over the Path
  • Catrice 5 in a Box Diamond Lavender Look
  • Etude Autumn Closet
  • Essence The Cool Nude edition
  • What’s Up Beauty Dragon Eye
  • Kaleidos Makeup Alma Viva Venus Trap
  • Dior Backstage Silver Essentials
  • Glossier Monochromes Mist
  • Victoria Beckham Beauty Smokey Eye Brick Tuxedo
  • Rom&nd Better Than Dreamy Lilac Garden
  • Lisa Eldridge Vega
  • Fantasy Cosmetica The Rogue
  • Glamshop Zimna Mocca
  • Gloss Gods New Neutrals Remixed

Want to shop the list? Check out this link. *

*Link leads to a list of affiliate links. If you choose to shop through this link I could make a small commission.

What palettes did you try this year?

Leave a Reply

I’m Maaike

Welcome to Floating in Dreams! Your one stop shop for all my online content. This features makeup reviews, vlogs, and lifestyle posts. Join my little online family and talk to you soon!

Let’s connect

Discover more from FLOATING IN DREAMS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading